I am making this post in good faith
In my last post I asked about securely hosting Jellyfin given my specific setup. A lot of people misunderstood my situation, which caused the whole thread to turn into a mess, and I didn’t get the help I needed.
I am very new to selfhosting, which means I don’t know everything. Instead of telling me that I don’t know something, please help me learn and understand. I am here asking for help, even if I am not very good at it, which I apologize for.
With that said, let me reoutline my situation:
I use my ISP’s default router, and the router is owned by Amazon. I am not the one managing the router, so I have no control over it. That alone means I have significant reason not to trust my own home network, and it means I employ the use of ProtonVPN to hide my traffic from my ISP and I require the use of encryption even over the LAN for privacy reasons. That is my threat model, so please respect that, even if you don’t agree with it. If you don’t agree with it, and don’t have any help to give, please bring your knowledge elsewhere, as your assistance is not required here. Thank you for being respectful!
Due to financial reasons, I can only use the free tier of ProtonVPN, and I want to avoid costs where I can. That means I can only host on the hardware I have, which is a Raspberry Pi 5, and I want to avoid the cost of buying a domain or using a third party provider.
I want to access Jellyfin from multiple devices, such as my phone, laptop, and computer, which means I’m not going to host Jellyfin on-device. I have to host it on a server, which is, in this case, the Raspberry Pi.
With that, I already have a plan for protecting the server itself, which I outlined in the other post, by installing securecore on it. Securing the server is a different project, and not what I am asking for help for here.
I want help encrypting the Jellyfin traffic in transit. Since I always have ProtonVPN enabled, and Android devices only have one VPN slot enabled, I cannot use something such as Tailscale for encryption. There is some hope in doing some manual ProtonVPN configurations, but I don’t know how that would work, so someone may be able to help with that.
All Jellyfin clients I have used (on Linux and Android) do not accept self-signed certificates. You can test this yourself by configuring Jellyfin to only accept HTTPS requests, using a self-signed certificate (without a domain), and trying to access Jellyfin from a client. This is a known limitation. I wouldn’t want to use self-signed certificates anyways, since an unknown intruder on the network could perform a MITM attack to decrypt traffic (or the router itself, however unlikely).
Even if I don’t trust my network, I can still verify the security and authenticity of the software I use in many, many ways. This is not the topic of this post, but I am mentioning it just in case.
Finally, I want to mention that ProtonVPN in its free tier does not allow LAN connections. The only other VPN providers I would consider are Mullvad VPN or IVPN, both of which are paid. I don’t intend to get rid of ProtonVPN, and again that is not the topic of this post.
Please keep things on-topic, and be respectful. Again, I am here to learn, which is why I am asking for help. I don’t know everything, so please keep that in mind. What are my options for encrypting Jellyfin traffic in transit, while prioritizing privacy and security?
The latter is not a requirement at all. Plenty of people have publicly-issued TLS certs for domain named services that aren’t exposed to the public internet, or aren’t using HTTP(s). If using LetsEncrypt, the DNS-01 challenge method would suffice, or can even issue a wildcard certificate for subdomains, so additional certificate issuance is not required.
If after acquiring a domain, said domain can be pointed to one of many free nameservers that provide an API which can be updated from an ACME script for automatic renewal of the LetsEncrypt certificate using DNS-01. dns.he.net is one such example.
OP has been given a variety of options, each of which come with their own tradeoffs. But public access to Jellyfin just to get a public cert is not a necessary tradeoff that OP needs to make.
Came to suggest this. I ran into the same problem when I tried to host Jellyfin at home. Also I was fed up with all those certificate warnings, depending on which device I used. Since I was already using pihole in my home network, I just went and looked at all the DNS plugins for certbot to learn which provider allows for easy DNS challenges. Then I researched a bit and stumbled upon a provider that was running a sale - so I got a domain for less than 5 bucks/year.
I set the public A record to 127.0.0.1 and configured certbot to use their API. This domain is now used internally in my network exclusively and I just added some DNS entries for several subdomains in pihole, so that it works for every device at home (e.g. jellyfin.example.com / dockerhost.example.com / proxmox.example.com / …).
When I’m away, I shouldn’t be able to resolve the domain, and even if DNS were hijacked, the TLS certificate will protect me from connecting to $randomServices. Also my router is less restricted, which means that I can just use it’s VPN server to connect directly to my home network, if I need to access my server or need to troubleshoot things when away.