Logline

When the USS Enterprise investigates an attack on a colony at the edge of Federation space, Captain Pike and his crew face the return of a formidable enemy.


Written by Henry Alonso Myers

Directed by Maja Vrvilo

  • Value Subtracted@startrek.websiteOPM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    41
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    The more I think about the Chapel plot, the more I think it was a blunder.

    If she survived the initial attack on the Cayuga, it’s likely that others did, too - at the very least, it should give Spock a reason to look before hot-dropping the saucer onto the planet.

    • eva_sieve@startrek.website
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      23
      ·
      1 year ago

      Gotta agree, it seems like an unforced error. A good chunk of the audience knows she shows up in TOS, which robs the whole idea of any tension it might have, and on top of that it feels plot armor-y to have one person survive and then not check for anyone else.

      They could’ve just contrived to have Spock and Chapel be the best persons for the saucer deorbiting-- Spock as the precise vulcan/science officer to place the thrusters, Chapel as medbay’s lead in case they could bring anyone back from the Cayuga.

      • Value Subtracted@startrek.websiteOPM
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        13
        ·
        1 year ago

        I’m fine with Chapel being stuck there - I think the tension comes from the overall Spock/Chapel emotional arc, rather than wondering whether she will survive - but the sequence practically demands a second scan with the newfangled tricorders to verify that there are no other life signs on the ship.

        • khaosworks@startrek.website
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          5
          ·
          1 year ago

          Isn’t the point though that the Gorn interference field was preventing any scans, comms or transport? The tricorder wouldn’t have worked there. And sending rescue teams would have been dangerous given Gorn belligerence, demarcation line or not.

            • khaosworks@startrek.website
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              3
              ·
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              True, but that’s on the ground and short range. There’s specific dialogue to show that it’s interfering with signals between space and ground.

              SPOCK: I detect a counter-frequency emanating from the planet. It appears to be negating all scans, communications, and transporter signals between here and there.

              Spock can’t even scan for life signs on Cayuga. The best they have is passive sensors like spectrometry.

              UNA: Still trying to scan for life signs?

              SPOCK: I theorized I might be able to find a frequency gap through the interference field, but I have not managed to discover one yet.

              UNA: Spock, I don’t think anyone’s alive over there.

              SPOCK: Spectrometric analysis suggests there are still pockets of oxygen on board. It is possible someone could have survived.

              That’s why they had to do a visual confirmation and discovered Cayuga’s sickbay had been blown away.

                • khaosworks@startrek.website
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  2
                  ·
                  1 year ago

                  I was just trying to answer the technological criticisms about why Spock didn’t search.

                  I see where the criticism is coming from, but I can also see there are all sorts of extenuating circumstances around it (not to mention lack of time) and to take the plot there for a search would kind of kill the story momentum.

                  It’s not invalid as a criticism, just saying that tech reasons are covered.

                  • vewave@kbin.social
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    2
                    ·
                    edit-2
                    1 year ago

                    I see where the criticism is coming from, but I can also see there are all sorts of extenuating circumstances around it (not to mention lack of time) and to take the plot there for a search would kind of kill the story momentum.

                    This is a blunder on writer’s/producer’s/etc. They could have written a one-off line where Spock cold-bloodedly says “the needs of the many outweighs the needs of the few.” They could have sent rescue shuttles to search the wreckage since it was on the right side of the line early on in the episode. They could have chosen an entirely different solution (seems like flying a shuttle disguised as wreck worked well, toss another stuffed with torpedoes).

                    It’s fine, they’ll lampshade it next season.

    • Zoboomafoo@yiffit.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      11
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Agreed, the entire saucer section was on the Federation side of the line of demarcation, they could have openly had rescue teams checking for survivors

      • JohnnyDelirious@startrek.website
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        1 year ago

        Which does raise the question of why there was a Gorn aboard the wreck of the Cayuga.

        The Gorn drew up the demarcation line and broadcast it to the Federation, held their fire as promised, and did not consider the arrival of another Gorn ship as a hostile action.

        So the Enterprise sending a shuttle to check the parts of the Cayuga’s wreckage for survivors is something that appears permitted and even expected, so long as it doesn’t cross the line.

        But any such rescue party would then bump into this lone Gorn who was very clearly violating the demarcation line that they themselves proposed.

        Sort of feels like the attack on the colony was unplanned, and that the later Gorn ship was playing damage control while trying to figure out what happened.

        • Zoboomafoo@yiffit.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          1 year ago

          Sort of feels like the attack on the colony was unplanned, and that the later Gorn ship was playing damage control while trying to figure out what happened.

          That’s consistent with what they theorized regarding the solar flares causing the first ship to attack the colony.

          That’s the best explanation I’ve heard, and I’m going to stick with it until a better one comes along

          • Tom Riley@mas.to
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            1 year ago

            @JohnnyDelirious @Zoboomafoo One moment Spok is frantically trying to find Chapel on the Kayuga, but then doesn’t even mention survivors when they plan to crash it. It’s too much of a stretch. There must be some key plot here they deliberately didn’t show us. We don’t see the initial attack on the Kayuga at all. Why was the lone Gorn (stuck?) on that side of the line trying to access command codes on a destroyed ship? I think we’ll get a revealing flashback in S03E01.

            • Zoboomafoo@yiffit.net
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              1 year ago

              Agreed about the survivors part, it seems like a major oversight that I hope they can explain in a satisfying way.

              As for the Gorn on the ship, I presumed it was just a crewman trying to gather intelligence on the Federation by picking through the remains of the saucer section